Discover Rainbow Shores, a charming inn on Lake Ontario, offering 4.2-star accommodations, exquisite dining, breathtaking views, and a pet-friendly atmosphere. Enjoy handcrafted culinary creations, live music, and unforgettable sunsets just steps from the
Recent guests highlight the scenic lakefront setting and excellent dining experience with live music, while noting simple, clean rooms that can have noticeable odors. The inn offers a relaxing atmosphere best suited for leisure visitors looking to enjoy nature and good food.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
Rainbow Shores, located at 186 S Rainbow Shores Rd in Pulaski, NY, is a hidden gem nestled along the tranquil shores of Lake Ontario. Boasting an impressive rating of 4.2, this quaint inn has captivated the hearts of many visitors. The beautiful scenery and warm hospitality make it an ideal retreat for anyone looking to unwind.
Guests have consistently praised the accommodating staff, with Brigitte, the hostess, often mentioned for her exceptional service. Tim Meyer shares a delightful experience, highlighting how Brigitte managed to seat him at a table with a breathtaking view of the lake, making his dining experience unforgettable. Not only is the service commendable, but the cuisine also impresses with an array of flavorful, handcrafted dishes. Many diners, like Amy Montondo and Sarah Record, rave about the exquisite food quality and stunning lakeside setting, emphasizing that the prices, while a bit steep, reflect the value of the experience offered.
The ambiance at Rainbow Shores is equally inviting. With Adirondack chairs placed strategically by the water, guests can relish the picturesque sunsets that have drawn many to this locale. Myrna Thompson, a repeat visitor, emphasizes the friendly nature of the staff and the culinary delights that keep her coming back each summer, while Michelle Hughes calls it an Epicurean's dream, celebrating the exceptional meals served under the expansive sky.
While the rooms may be on the smaller side, guests often find them clean and quaint. DM describes a serene deck that overlooks the water, perfect for relaxation, despite some noting a strong odor in certain areas. However, the overwhelming charm and scenic beauty more than compensate for minor inconveniences.
Rainbow Shores is not only about the lodging; it offers a wealth of nearby activities. Visitors can explore Selkirk Shores State Park, Sandy Island Beach State Park, and Southwick Beach State Park, making it a great destination for nature lovers and adventure seekers alike. With amenities like free Wi-Fi, pet-friendly options, and a smoke-free environment, this hotel promises a comfortable stay for all guests.
In conclusion, Rainbow Shores is an enchanting retreat that provides a perfect blend of relaxation, delicious dining, and stunning views. Whether soaking in the sunset from a lakeside chair or indulging in a delightful meal, guests leave with cherished memories and a desire to return. This slice of paradise is undeniably worth a visit.
The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
Fabulous experience all around. We had no reservations. Brigitte, the hostess, was so accommodating. She checked with the kitchen and gladly seated us with a great view of Lake Ontario. The food and service were as great as the view. Highly recommended.
We stayed at the RS for one night. The room was on the small side but clean and quaint. It does smell like moth balls. The location is the best part with Adirondack chairs to sit in by the water to enjoy the sunset. We also ate dinner here. They have a nice selection of dishes. It is a little pricey but I would say worth it. Service was excellent and the view from the deck can't be beat. We also really enjoyed the live music. Expect your dining experience to be at least 2 hours. It takes a while to get a table, drink and meal. But if you aren't in a hurry, definitely go here for dinner and sit and relax.
We enjoyed flavorful,hand crafted culinary creations plus live music & picturesque lake side dining. Seriously can’t say more positive words other than it’s definitely worth the trip! Enjoy!! I didn’t stay in their little lakeside cabin. Just re visited this year and it was even better!
My daughter introduced me to Rainbow Shores , where she has been staying in the summer for quite a long time So I’ve been going there for three years I believe The owner and staff are very kind The food is great ! And we love the entertainment
There is no restaurant on Lake Ontario like it. It is an Epicurean's dream! I have been there four times this season and the food, drinks, service and sunsets are simply amazing. This slice of heaven envelops you upon entering. Bridgette, the manager, greats you with a world class smile, friendly manner and magnetic personality. The complimentary warm homemade buns and butter served while your food is being prepared are delish! They have all-you-can-eat crab legs on Thursday nights. The Lake Ontario sunsets are rated in the Top 10 Sunsets in the World in Condé Nast Travel Magazine. This restaurant will be awarded a three-star Michelin Rating someday!
Remote and simple room. Enjoyed sitting out on the deck looking at the water. Restaurant at a great location on the water and service was excellent. Be prepared to relax and take the time to wait for your food. Room, though clean had a strong smell we ended up getting used too. The beach on the other hand is not a beach to sit at unless you can get used to the strong smell of dead fish coming from the uncared for beach next to the property.
On the shores of Lake Ontario, this quaint inn with a restaurant is 4 miles from Sandy Island Beach State Park, and 6 miles from Salmon River Lighthouse & Marina. It’s 7 miles from Interstate 81.
Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in New York. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.
1,265 reviews 7101 State Rte 3, Pulaski, NY 13142, United States
861 reviews 3387 County Rte 15, Pulaski, NY 13142, United States
608 reviews County Rte 40, Mexico, NY 13114, United States
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Discover Gogebic Lodge in Marenisco, MI, offering outdoor fun, great cuisine, and stunning lake views. Ideal for fishing, hiking, ...
Discover serenity at Island Spa Catalina, rated 4.7, where lush botanical gardens meet breathtaking views. Enjoy exquisite spa tre...
Discover The Ram's Head Inn, a 4.4star gem in Shelter Island Heights, NY. Enjoy elegant accommodations, breathtaking views, and e...
Discover THE BERGSON, a 4.5star upscale inn in the heart of California's wine country. Enjoy cozy rooms with fireplaces, deliciou...
Discover The DeBruce, a charming 4.5star hotel nestled along Willowemoc Creek. Enjoy stunning views, exceptional dining, and warm...
Experience tranquility at Shou Sugi Ban House, nestled in Water Mill, NY. Enjoy luxurious spa treatments, stunning grounds, and wa...
Experience the ultimate retreat at Sandy Point Resort & Disc Golf Ranch in Lac Du Flambeau, WI. With a 4.8star rating, enjoy thri...
Discover The Inn Hotel, Ascend Hotel Collection, a modern and welcoming hotel in Arnolds Park, IA. Enjoy our comfortable accommoda...
Experience the warmth of community at Blue Bluff Harbor, a charming lakeside haven rated 4.3 stars. Enjoy friendly service, delici...
Experience luxury at Echo Canyon Spa Resort, a 4.7rated adultsonly haven nestled in nature. Enjoy exquisite dining, rejuvenating...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
